Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

Sign In Apply for Membership

Categories

Please refrain from copy and pasting messages over and over and over, or you will be removed from the forum. We all have input to make so let's keep this at a discussion and not a text block of commercials. Here are some helpful guidelines for good discussion and debate recommended by one of our members:

  • * Stay on topic
  • * Be clear
  • * Build upon your points and address those of other people
  • * Refrain from making assumptions about others' unstated views
  • * If you disagree with somebody, do so politely
  • * Clarify your terms and seek to understand others' (but avoid semantic derails)
Note: The opinions expressed by the moderators and members of this discussion board do not necessarily reflect the opinions of Occupy Together or Occupy Wall St. In the spirit of free information, open discussion, and the freedom of expression, members are able to speak about issues relating and directly pertaining to the Occupy movement. You will be banned for hate speech or intentional misinformation and please refrain from any violent rhetoric; this is a peaceful movement. Thank you.
Liberal or Conservative
  • NoMore February 2012 +1 -1
    I've been thinking of a question that I asked myself, but I've been unable to answer. So, I open it to discussion in the hope of finding an acceptable answer. Knowing the life and the teachings of Jesus, if Jesus was alive today would he be considered a Liberal or a Conservative? Please chime in with your thoughts.
  • Leo February 2012 +1 -1
    As someone who has studied religious texts and history, I know that there are several 'Jesus'. The Jesus of Paul, the Jesus of the gospel ascribed to Mark, the Jesus of the gospel ascribed to Matthew, the Jesus of the gospel ascribed to Luke, the Jesus of the gospel ascribed to John, the various Jesus of non-canoncical gospels, and the historical Jesus are all different. The historical Jesus would be considered a terrorist by both modern American and ancient Roman standards (which is why he was crucified in association with an insurrection). Thus, he was a conservative. The 'Nosri' name of the group he belonged to meant 'Keepers' (of the Torah). The Jesus of Paul would have been no less conservative despite the position on circumcision. However, as a Jewish man whose Nosri membership was of a Pharisee affiliation, the historical Jesus would have been considered a liberal by the conservative Sadducees. In contrast, by today's Jewish standards, he would be considered Orthodox if not Ultra-Orthodox.

    This leaves the various Jesus characters of the gospel accounts. Despite all of the emphasis placed on mercy, forgiveness, and generosity, from these characters, none of these aspects make the Torah-keeping lifestyle of any of the gospel Jesus characters any less conservative than religious people of today. Though criticism of social hypocrisy may be leveled by these characters ( eg. "Let he who is without sin cast the first stone."), there is nothing expressed through them that would classify any of them as being liberal. Nothing suggests that any of them would be against capital punishment in general, slavery, subservient wives, or for abortion and gay marriage. On the contrary, all of the characters are portrayed to have engaged in violent action in opposition to the standard custom of hosting a marketplace in the Court of the Gentiles.